Why “reasonable compensation” matters

For many S corporation owners, the attraction of the S corporation structure is the ability to receive both wages for services and shareholder distributions. But the tax treatment is not simply a matter of choosing a salary number that produces the lowest payroll tax. When an owner performs meaningful services for the corporation, the IRS expects the owner to be treated as an employee and paid wages that are reasonable for those services.

The IRS states that corporate officers are generally employees when they perform services and receive or are entitled to compensation. For S corporations, payments to an officer must be treated as wages to the extent they represent reasonable compensation for services. The IRS can reclassify distributions or other payments as wages, which can create additional employment taxes, interest, penalties and professional fees.

The practical lesson is simple: do not start with the question, “How little salary can I pay myself?” Start with, “What would I have to pay someone else to perform the work I actually do?” Then document how you arrived at the answer.

What the IRS looks at

There is no single IRS table that says an owner of a particular S corporation must be paid a specific percentage of revenue. Reasonableness is a facts-and-circumstances question. IRS guidance identifies several factors that can help support the analysis.

Start with the services performed by the shareholder. The IRS specifically points to the source of the corporation’s gross receipts: shareholder services, services of non-shareholder employees, or capital and equipment. If the business earns most of its revenue because of the owner’s personal services, a larger portion of the owner’s total compensation generally belongs in wages.

Other factors include training and experience, duties and responsibilities, time and effort devoted to the business, dividend history, compensation paid to non-shareholder employees, the timing and manner of bonuses, comparable pay for similar services, compensation agreements and any formula used to determine compensation.

A useful analysis therefore looks beyond the owner’s title. A shareholder who sells, manages staff, performs technical work, handles customers and makes the major operating decisions is performing several jobs. The compensation analysis should reflect the actual work—not merely the title printed on a business card.

How to build a defensible compensation file

A strong reasonable-compensation file is more valuable than a number pulled from a generic online calculator. Begin with a written description of the owner’s duties. Estimate the time spent on sales, production, administration, management, customer service and other revenue-producing activities.

Next, gather comparable compensation information. Sources may include reputable salary surveys, industry compensation studies, job postings for similar roles, professional associations and compensation data for employees doing similar work. Adjust for geography, experience, company size, responsibilities and the amount of time actually worked.

Then document the decision. The file should show the date of the determination, the duties considered, the compensation data reviewed, the assumptions made and the final salary selected. If circumstances change materially—such as a large increase in revenue, a major change in duties, the hiring of a management team or a substantial reduction in the owner’s hours—review the compensation again.

Remember that wages are only one part of the picture. Payroll withholding, employer payroll taxes, retirement contributions, health benefits and other compensation arrangements may also affect the overall compensation package and the corporation’s compliance obligations.

A practical year-end review

Reasonable compensation should not be treated as a once-a-decade decision. Review it periodically, particularly before year-end tax planning. Compare the owner’s current duties and compensation with the business’s financial performance and the compensation of people performing similar work.

An S corporation should also keep payroll records consistent with the compensation decision. A situation in which an owner takes large distributions throughout the year but reports little or no wages deserves attention. Conversely, the goal is not to inflate wages without a business reason. The objective is compensation that can be explained and supported.

If the business has multiple owners, employees or revenue streams, the analysis may become more complicated. Different owners may perform very different functions, and distributions may not correspond to compensation. Keep the compensation analysis separate from the shareholder’s economic ownership interest.

The best time to fix a compensation problem is before it becomes an examination issue. If you are unsure whether your current salary is supportable, gather the facts, document the analysis and have the compensation reviewed before filing the return.

Action Checklist

Use this checklist to turn the information in this report into a practical next step:

☐ List every significant service you perform for the S corporation.

☐ Estimate the percentage of your working time devoted to each function.

☐ Identify which activities directly produce revenue and which support employees, assets or operations.

☐ Gather at least two or three credible compensation benchmarks for comparable work.

☐ Adjust the comparison for geography, experience, duties, company size and hours worked.

☐ Document the date, sources, assumptions and conclusion of your compensation analysis.

☐ Review payroll, W-2 wages and shareholder distributions for consistency with the analysis.

☐ Revisit compensation when duties, hours, revenue sources or staffing change materially.

☐ Keep the supporting documentation with the corporation’s permanent tax records.

☐ Ask your tax professional to review the analysis before making a major year-end compensation decision.

Important note

Federal tax rules can depend on facts, dates, entity structure, documents and the taxpayer’s complete circumstances. This article is general educational information and is not legal or individualized tax advice. State tax rules may differ. Consult your tax or legal professional before relying on a conclusion for a specific matter.

IRS references used for this report

IRS — S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporation-compensation-and-medical-insurance-issues

IRS — S corporation employees, shareholders and corporate officers
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporation-employees-shareholders-and-corporate-officers

IRS — Instructions for Form 1120-S
https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i1120s

If you have any questions or want to get on a consultation call,

Book an appointment on my calendly page https://calendly.com/lpbkpro/30minutes

You can email me at ralphp@lptaxandbookkeepingpros.com

You can call me at 303-881-9762